Best Italian Restaurants in St. Johns

This beloved Italian-American chain location at St. Johns Town Center delivers generous family-style portions and warm, bustling atmosphere that keeps locals and visitors coming back, as evidenced by its impressive 4.5-star rating from over 5,000 reviews. Diners consistently rave about the authentic recipes, attentive service, and lively dining room that captures the spirit of a traditional Italian family gathering. Make reservations for dinner service, especially on weekends, as this popular spot fills up quickly with families and groups looking to share hearty Italian classics.

Serafina's Pizzeria has earned a devoted local following with its consistently excellent food and welcoming atmosphere, as evidenced by nearly 1,600 glowing reviews and an impressive 4.8-star rating. This St. Johns gem offers diverse menu options beyond pizza, making it perfect for groups with different tastes who all want quality at reasonable prices. Visit during off-peak hours to snag a table more easily, as this popular spot can get busy thanks to its stellar reputation among both locals and travelers.

Vito's Italian Restaurant has earned a devoted local following with its authentic Italian atmosphere and consistently delicious fare, as evidenced by over 1,100 glowing reviews and an impressive 4.6-star rating. Travelers rave about the welcoming family-friendly vibe and generous portions that showcase traditional Italian flavors without breaking the bank. For the best experience, arrive early during weekend dinner hours as this popular neighborhood gem tends to fill up quickly with both locals and visitors in the know.

Midtown Table has earned a devoted following among Jacksonville diners with its diverse menu offerings and consistently excellent execution, as evidenced by over 1,000 glowing reviews averaging 4.5 stars. The restaurant's appeal lies in its ability to satisfy varied tastes while maintaining quality across different cuisines, making it a reliable choice for groups with different preferences. Visit during off-peak hours to fully appreciate the atmosphere and give yourself time to explore their extensive menu options.

Despite its name suggesting Italian fare, Bella Vista offers an impressive variety of cuisines that has earned it a stellar 4.7-star rating from nearly 1,000 satisfied diners. This Fruit Cove gem clearly delivers on both quality and consistency, making it a reliable choice for travelers seeking a memorable meal with diverse options to please any palate. With such strong local support, arrive early during peak dinner hours as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly.

Dolce Vita Modern Italian brings contemporary flair to classic Italian cuisine in Jacksonville's Tapestry Park, creating an atmosphere that feels both sophisticated and welcoming. With an impressive 4.7-star rating from over 500 diners, travelers consistently rave about the quality of food and service that makes this spot a local favorite. Make reservations ahead of time, especially for weekend dinners, as this popular gem tends to fill up quickly with both locals and visitors seeking an elevated Italian dining experience.

Bellissimo Bistro has won over locals and visitors alike with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that caters to every palate, earning an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 300 satisfied diners. The restaurant's popularity stems from consistently delivering quality dishes across various cuisines, making it a reliable choice whether you're craving comfort food or seeking something more adventurous. Given its strong reputation and location on charming Quidi Vidi Road, consider making a reservation during peak dining hours to secure your spot at this St. John's favorite.