Home › Where to Eat › Best Italian Restaurants in St. John's
Best Italian Restaurants in St. John's

Best Italian Restaurants in St. John's

Curated guide featuring 7 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars

Home › Where to Eat › Best Italian Restaurants in St. John's

St. John's may be known for its rugged coastlines and maritime heritage, but tucked throughout this charming Newfoundland city is a thriving Italian food scene that would make any nonna proud. From cozy family-run trattorias serving up generations-old recipes to modern bistros putting creative spins on classic dishes, the Italian restaurants here offer something truly special. What sets St. John's apart is the genuine warmth of these establishments - owners who greet regulars by name, chefs who aren't afraid to come out and chat about their signature sauces, and an atmosphere that transforms every meal into a celebration of good food and good company.

In this guide, we've rounded up 10 exceptional Italian restaurants that have earned their stellar reputations one perfect plate of pasta at a time. Each spot featured here boasts ratings of 4.5 stars or higher, with an impressive collective average of 4.6 stars across thousands of reviews. Whether you're craving wood-fired pizza with perfectly charred edges, house-made gnocchi that melts on your tongue, or a romantic dinner complete with candlelight and Chianti, these restaurants deliver authentic Italian experiences that will have you planning your next visit before you've even finished dessert.

Featured Restaurants

Maggiano's Little Italy
$$

Maggiano's Little Italy

★★★★☆
4.5
(5,220 reviews)

This beloved Italian-American chain location in St. Johns Town Center delivers generous family-style portions and warm, old-world atmosphere that has earned rave reviews from over 5,000 diners. Travelers consistently praise the restaurant for its shareable pasta dishes, attentive service, and lively ambiance that's perfect for groups and special occasions. Make reservations ahead of time, especially on weekends, as this popular spot fills up quickly with both locals and visitors exploring Jacksonville's premier shopping district.

St. Johns Town Center, 10367 Mid Town Pkwy, Jacksonville, FL 32246, USA
Serafina's Pizzeria
$$

Serafina's Pizzeria

★★★★☆
4.8
(1,605 reviews)

This beloved St Johns pizzeria has earned an impressive 4.8-star rating from over 1,600 diners who rave about its consistently delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. With such overwhelmingly positive reviews, Serafina's has clearly mastered the art of satisfying both locals and visitors with quality dishes that keep people coming back. Given its popularity and excellent reputation, consider calling ahead during peak dinner hours to ensure you snag a table at this community favorite.

4125 Race Track Rd, St Johns, FL 32259, USA
Vito's Italian Restaurant
$$

Vito's Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆
4.6
(1,142 reviews)

Vito's Italian Restaurant has earned a devoted local following with its warm, authentic atmosphere that makes every meal feel like dining at a friend's family table. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 1,100 reviews, travelers consistently praise the generous portions, friendly service, and that perfect neighborhood trattoria vibe that's become increasingly rare. Make reservations for weekend evenings when the place buzzes with energy, and don't hesitate to ask your server for their personal recommendations.

116 Bartram Oaks Walk, St Johns, FL 32259, USA
Midtown Table
$$

Midtown Table

★★★★☆
4.5
(1,070 reviews)

Midtown Table has earned a stellar reputation among Jacksonville diners with its diverse menu offerings and welcoming atmosphere that draws both locals and visitors alike. With over 1,000 glowing reviews averaging 4.5 stars, travelers consistently praise the quality and variety that makes it easy to satisfy different tastes in one spot. For the best experience, consider making a reservation during peak dinner hours since this popular Gate Parkway gem tends to fill up quickly.

5016 Gate Pkwy #6, Jacksonville, FL 32256, USA
Bella Vista Italian Restaurant
$$

Bella Vista Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆
4.7
(972 reviews)

Bella Vista Italian Restaurant has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with nearly 1,000 glowing reviews praising its welcoming atmosphere and consistently delicious Italian fare. The impressive 4.7-star rating speaks to the restaurant's ability to deliver satisfying meals at reasonable prices, making it a reliable choice for both casual dinners and special occasions. For the best experience, consider making reservations during peak dining hours, as this popular Fruit Cove gem tends to fill up quickly with repeat customers who know a good thing when they taste it.

540 State Rd 13 N, Fruit Cove, FL 32259, USA
Dolce Vita Modern Italian
$$

Dolce Vita Modern Italian

★★★★☆
4.7
(536 reviews)

Dolce Vita Modern Italian brings contemporary flair to classic Italian cuisine in Jacksonville's Tapestry Park area, creating an upscale yet welcoming atmosphere that has earned rave reviews from over 500 diners. The consistently high 4.7-star rating speaks to their reliable quality and service, making it a favorite among locals and visitors seeking authentic Italian flavors with a modern twist. Make reservations ahead of time, especially for weekend dinners, as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly.

9823 Tapestry Park Circle Suite 1, Jacksonville, FL 32246, USA
Bellissimo Bistro
$$

Bellissimo Bistro

★★★★☆
4.6
(329 reviews)

Bellissimo Bistro has earned its stellar 4.6-star reputation among locals and visitors alike with its diverse menu that caters to every palate, creating a welcoming atmosphere where quality meets variety. With over 300 glowing reviews, diners consistently praise this Quidi Vidi Road gem for delivering exceptional food and service that keeps them coming back. Given its popularity and prime location, consider making a reservation, especially during weekend evenings when this beloved neighborhood spot tends to fill up quickly.

123 Quidi Vidi Rd, St. John's, NL A1A 1C3, Canada

Culinary Experiences in St. John's

Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences